From 2010 to 2015 Public sector job losses reached 1 million. There were 6,340,000 people paid by the public purse in March 2010 - but only 5,347,000 by the end of 2015[P 1] (WORK IN PROGRESS)
- 1 109 Jobcentres closed
- 2 535 Libraries closed
- 3 1000 Sure Start centres closed
- 4 103 NHS clinics closed
- 5 35 Fire stations closed
- 6 18 Prisons closed
- 7 17 A&E wards closed
- 8 21,000 Police officers lost
- 9 14,000 Nurses lost
- 10 Public Sector Cuts References
- 11 Jobcentre References
- 12 Library References
- 13 Sure Start References
- 14 NHS Clinics References
- 15 Fire stations References
- 16 Prisons References
- 17 References
109 Jobcentres closed
The Tory party have been carrying out a programme of closing Jobcentres.[J 1] The reason given for this is that they are no longer required due to the low unemployment figures. They also state that the PFI contracts have reached the end of the 20 year contract and so will not be renewed on these centres[J 2].
Support for the long-term unemployed and disabled jobseekers has also been cut. A new Work and Health Programme will assist less than a quarter of the participants of the programmes it replaced. Across the country, hundreds of specialist organisations working with jobseekers have lost contracts, and thousands of experienced employment advisers have lost their jobs.[J 3]
And all this is happening when the roll-out of the new, catch-all benefit called Universal Credit, is accelerating. By the end of 2018, most new working age claimants in Britain, will be claiming Universal Credit[J 4] – and many of them will be required to attend jobcentres. The already intense pressure on a shrinking network of jobcentres will increase further in 2019 when the Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) will begin moving millions of existing benefit claimants onto Universal Credit.
Mandatory personal attendance at jobcentre interviews remains a core requirement of continuing to receive Universal Credit and most other working age benefits. This is especially the case for unemployed claimants who must currently attend their jobcentre at least weekly, or fortnightly if their travel time is less than one hour each way by public transport. Where there is no public transport, they still have to attend every two weeks if they can walk to the jobcentre in under one hour or must walk no more than three miles each way. Claimants outside these limits, or those with particular barriers such as caring needs, are allowed to “sign on”, or report on their work search, fortnightly by post – but they must still travel to the jobcentre to attend more intensive interviews concerning their benefit claim and efforts to seek or prepare for work.[J 5]
Since mid-2016, the headline unemployment total has been falling – a data point measured by the household-based Labour Force Survey, which includes unemployed people who aren’t claiming benefits. But the claimant unemployment count, which includes those currently receiving Jobseekers Allowance and those on Universal Credit who are expected to work, has steadily increased. In the year to March 2018, it grew by 9% or 73,200 to reach a total of 890,500 claimants.
This increase has been most marked in the areas where Universal Credit has been implemented, and even more so in “full digital service” areas. In the relatively small number of jobcentres where the full service had been implemented longest, before 2016, the claimant count was 38% higher in March 2018 than it had been a year earlier, an increase that wasn’t experienced by those jobcentres where the full service had not yet been implemented. While the final trend is not certain, an analysis by the Learning and Work Institute suggests it’s plausible that the number of unemployed claimants could double to 1.5m by the end of 2020. Yet the DWP and jobcentres have only a third of the resources and staffing that they had in 2012, the last time the claimant count stood at that total.
Frances Ryan of the Guardian said "Shutting down jobcentres is the austerity era’s most underhand cut yet. Protests about one north London closure are just a drop in the ocean. One in 10 jobcentres will be cut over the next year". https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2017/nov/02/shutting-down-jobcentres-austerity-underhand-cut
535 Libraries closed
The figure of 535 is intentionally on the low side to ensure that the figure is not exaggerated. It is likely to be much higher by now (June 2018). Many libraries that were closed by councils were then re-opened by voluntary organisations. 525 libraries had closed by 2016, with a further 111 closures planned for the year.
Spending on public libraries in the UK Overview CIPFA are the recognised source of official information on public libraries. CIPFA public library comparators are free, publicly available and give a detailed breakdown per city or regions.
There are four areas - Sefton in Merseyside; Brent in north London, Stoke-on-Trent and Sunderland - where more than half the libraries have closed since 2010, either buildings, mobile or both. The below table shows number of libraries closed in the period 2010 to March 2016. The data was collected by the BBC via a freedom of information request. Of the 525 libraries closed a number moved in to the voluntary sector. A further 111 libraries were identified for closure in 2016 at the time this data was compiled.[L 3]
|Council run libraries in 2010||4290|
|Council run libraries as at 29 March 2016||3765|
|Reduction in council run libraries||525|
The number of paid staff in libraries fell from 31,977 in 2010 to 24,044 now, a drop of 7,933 (25%) for the 182 library authorities that provided comparable data, while the slack was taken up by 15,000 volunteers.[L 4]
One of the impacts of libraries moving into the voluntary sector is that they are reliant on council grants to continue. These grants are uncertain as councils face further tightening of their budgets going forward. Public Library News keeps a list of libraries closed[L 5], although the list may not be comprehensive as some closures are not known.
Further to closures, more libraries are moving to a limited service to cut costs. The image below shows the number of libraries that open more than 10 hours per week and how the number has dropped during the last 10 years.
The figures below show a drop in spending of 38.6% from its peak in 2009/10 if one takes in to account inflation. This is likely to be an exaggeration, however, as spending on staff salaries has been frozen (or nearly so: it has been 1% the year before last. 2% this) for the last five years and staffing represents a large percentage of overall library costs. If one ignores inflation completely, the decline from peak is more than halved at 18%. The true answer will likely be somewhere between the two figures. The figures are taken from the official Cipfa statistics.
Gov.uk (September 2017). “In 2016/17, 34.0% of adults had used a public library service in the 12 months prior to interview. This is significantly lower than in 2005/06 (48.2%) but similar to 2015/16 (33.4%).”
1000 Sure Start centres closed
Sure Start was created and developed as a way of improving the educational and life chances of socially and economically disadvantaged children. The centres offered families access to services including childcare, healthcare, parenting classes, job skills and playgroups.
By 2010, there were 3,600 centres in the UK. Before that year’s general election, the Conservative leader at the time, David Cameron, promised to protect funding for Sure Start, but this pledge quickly evaporated amid swingeing cuts to local authority budgets.
Over the next seven years, early years provision bore the brunt of cuts to children’s services. According to a study carried out by the National Audit Office, released in March 2018, Sure Start budgets in England were reduced by £763m (50%) between 2010 and 2017, as councils focused scarce funds on meeting an explosion in demand for child protection services.
According to the Sutton Trust, an education and social mobility foundation, a lack of clarity in how individual centres are identified and changes are reported means official figures of 500 closures since 2010 are likely to be an underestimate. According to study carried out by Sutton Trust research, the number of closures are 30%, not 14% as reported by the government, with closures more likely exceeding 1000 centres.[S 1]
After 2010, the budget for Sure Start was no longer ring-fenced, but merged with other programmes. By 2013, national guidance on the ‘core purpose’ of children’s centres shifted focus to targeting ‘high need’ families, rather than open access to universal services.
- The national database recorded a 14% drop in centre numbers between 2009 and October 2017. However, there is no clear definition of a ‘children’s centre’ and therefore many closures announced locally were not yet reflected in the database: our survey showed a 16% drop. If we only count ‘registered centres’, the drop since 2009 was more than 30%, suggesting that more than 1,000 centres nationally might have closed.
- By 2017, sixteen authorities closing 50% or more of their centres accounted for 55% of the total number of closures nationally. Six authorities (West Berkshire, Camden, Stockport, Bromley, Oxfordshire and Staffordshire) had closed more than 70% of their centres. Despite this reduction, the proportion of centres in the 30% most disadvantaged areas remained constant from 2009 to 2017 at just over 50%. So, numbers dropped but the focus on disadvantaged areas remained.
- More centres operate on a part-time basis only and the number of services has fallen. While most centres still offer open access services to families of all backgrounds, these have been reduced, restricted to fewer centres or to fewer sessions. Six out of ten local authorities reported most centres were open full-time; but few or none were open full-time in almost one in five authorities. Reduced services were reported by 55% of local authorities, with only 35% providing a range of ten or more services.
- Financial pressures came top in 84% of local authorities as a principal driver of change in recent years. This financial squeeze since the removal of ring-fencing is intensifying, with 69% of authorities reporting a budget decrease in the last two years.
- Change of focus’ came a close second (80%) as a driver of change. This was not just a move towards greater targeting of individual high need families and away from open access. It was also a way of integrating children’s centres into a wider package of ‘early help’ as part of local teams with a much wider age range (0-19), with more than 40% of authorities extending the age range to include school age children.
- Changed national and local priorities have played a part. The suspension of Ofsted inspections and the lack of any national guidance since 2013 on the purpose of children’s centres were seen in our survey as reducing the importance of children’s centres. The effect was to reduce the strength of children’s centres in local authority priorities.
103 NHS clinics closed
For this section the headline number understates the number of clinics closed or being closed.
Walk-in centres were one of the last Labour government’s flagship NHS policies. About 230 of them opened in England in the 2000s when Tony Blair and Gordon Brown were in Downing Street.Designed to provide an alternative to A&E and GP services, they were popular with patients.
By January 2018 it was estimated that 95 had closed, 40% of the orginal number.[H 1]
Holly Maltby, a campaigner at 38 Degrees, blamed the closures on government underfunding of the NHS. “Each time an NHS service is cut through lack of funding, it piles pressure on remaining services.”
On top of walk in clinics being closed,maternity units and community hospitals are being closed. 38 Degrees found that at least 70 services had shut or been downgraded.
The urgent care centre in the centre of Walsall will probably close, even though it opened only last year at a cost of £1 million, under money-saving plans being considered by the town’s NHS clinical commissioning group. The CCG wants to shut the centre to save £951,000 in running costs because not enough patients go there to justify it staying open, it says.
Seven mental health services are at risk of closure, despite mental illness being a top government priority. They include Newholme hospital in Bakewell, Derbyshire, which will go as part of the NHS’s plans to provide more care closer to patients’ homes.
The impending closure of nine GP practices will force the 45,000 patients affected to find a new family doctors, 38 Degrees says.
35 Fire stations closed
Again the figure in the headline understates the true figure. The FBU gives the figure at over 40 by 2018.
Since 2010, more than 11,000 firefighter jobs have been cut across the UK – one-in-five frontline firefighter jobs, hitting wholetime, retained and control firefighters.[F 1]
The government intends to cut it's funding to the fire and rescue service by 20% during the course of this parliament. In the last parliament they cut it by 30%.[F 2]
As a result 11,000 frontline firefighter jobs have gone since 2010 - that is one in six. Stations, appliances and equipment have also been cut. The cuts have been imposed against the background of increased fire deaths in England. New Home Office figures show that in the year ending September 2017, there were 346 fire-related fatalities (including 71 from the Grenfell Tower fire) compared with 253 in the previous year – a 37% increase (up 9% not including Grenfell). 2015-2016 saw a 15% rise in fire deaths compared with the year before.
Since 2010, firefighters have been axed, dozens of fire stations have closed, fire engines have been scrapped and levels of emergency rescue equipment has been slashed. In London alone, 10 fire stations have been closed, 27 fire engines axed and more than 600 firefighter posts have been cut. Every year response times are increasing and 2015-2016 saw a 15% rise in fire deaths compared with the year before.
The video details the levels of cuts the Fire service has suffered since 2010, including the number of firefighters lost, number of stations closed and the number of appliances removed. It also covers so real cases where due to the cuts the Fire service has been unable to meet response times, leading to deaths.
A full analysis of Fire Service cuts can be found here
18 Prisons closed
The table below lists the prisons closed.[G 1] These prisons are to be replaced by mega-prisons, with the intention of closing smaller prisons and moving inmates to a regional larger prison.
|Bullwood Hall||Hockley||Essex||Closed 2013|
|Camp Hill Prison||Newport||Isle of Wight||Closed 2013|
|Canterbury Prison||Canterbury||Kent||Closed 2013|
|Glen Parva||Leicester||Leicestershire||Closed 2017 (Young offenders)|
|Latchmere House||Richmond upon Thames||London||Closed 2011|
|Shepton Mallet||Shepton Mallet||Somerset||Closed 2013|
The closures have come despite an increase in the number of prisoners. This has reduced the number of prisoner places available, while the prison population has risen by approximately 1300.[G 2]
|August 2010||June 2018||Change|
The prison population increased sharply since 2000, so is not a recent phenomenon. The Howard League has drawn to the government's attention to the growing prison population as against fewer prisons, reduced resources and a vastly reduced prison workforce.
The Howard League reported "While the prison population continues to grow, the money and resources available to manage that population growth is simply not there. More and more we see prisoners lying on their bunks with little positive to do. There are problems of prison suicides, rising violence and drug abuse behind bars."[G 3]
Those who have observed the prison estate at close quarters have been uniformly shocked by what they have witnessed and what they have been told. Peter Clarke, was asked by the Ministry of Justice in 2016 to investigate the prison estate. He notes as a matter of “particular concern” the 40 to 50 violent incidents each month. Every two days a member of staff is assaulted. Ex-offender and former drug abuser Mark Johnson founded the charity User Voice to encourage prisoner rehabilitation. “Being incarcerated in this country at the moment,” he says, “is being in a system tantamount to torture. You’re in a place of chaos. You may have left behind a life of chaos but it’s like going from frying pan into the fire.”[G 4]
17 A&E wards closed
The six A&Es that are under threat include those at Grantham hospital in Lincolnshire, Poole hospital in Dorset and Huddersfield royal infirmary and Dewsbury and district hospital, both in Yorkshire. https://www.healthbusinessuk.net/news/15112017/nhs-services-close-due-money-problems
21,000 Police officers lost
There are 46,000 less police, including civilian roles, now than when the Tories came to power
14,000 Nurses lost
Public Sector Cuts References
- Loss of overall public sector jobs between 2010 and 2015 https://www.mirror.co.uk/news/uk-news/public-sector-job-losses-set-7566903
- List of closed Job Centres closed since October 2017 (3 remain to be closed later this year) https://www.gov.uk/government/news/update-on-the-future-of-dwp-jobcentres?utm_source=c8215d84-41bc-499e-9922-35cd81abf8f1&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=govuk-notifications&utm_content=immediate#history
- Home Office paper that details Job Centres to be closed and their reasoning https://www.gov.uk/government/news/new-streamlined-jobcentre-plus-network-with-more-support-for-jobseekers
- Why are Job Centres closing and what are the impacts https://theconversation.com/why-are-britains-jobcentres-disappearing-91290
- What is it like to transition onto universal credit https://theconversation.com/what-its-like-to-transition-on-to-universal-credit-85190
- Claimant commitment and sanction details. https://revenuebenefits.org.uk/universal-credit/guidance/entitlement-to-uc/claimant-commitment/
- Libraries: For our survey a library is defined as a service point. A service point is any library, static or mobile, through which the public library authority provides or directly manages a service to the general public. A static service point must allow access to the general public (not just specific groups), and as a minimum, provide a staffed information point, stock loan facilities and a public access terminal. Departments within a single building should not be counted separately. Central libraries and branch libraries are counted as separate service points.
- Spending on public libraries falls by £66m in a year 11-12-2017 http://www.cipfa.org/about-cipfa/press-office/archived-press-releases/2017-press-releases/spending-on-public-libraries-falls-by-%C2%A366m-in-a-year?crdm=0
- Libraries lose a quarter of staff as hundreds close https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-england-35707956
- BBC News - Changes to UK libraries https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1HlnlL66ycQChlgl-exXXG6Yb10NylLX89VcJR-9pL8o/edit#gid=0
- List of withdrawn libraries http://www.publiclibrariesnews.com/about-public-libraries-news/news-topics
Sure Start References
NHS Clinics References
- Mass closure of NHS walk-in centres is fuelling winter crisis, claim campaigners - published 7-Jan18: https://www.theguardian.com/society/2018/jan/07/closure-nhs-walk-in-centres-nhs-winter-crisis-hospitals-services-medical
Fire stations References
- Cuts to the fire service are putting lives at risk - Andrew Scattergood 15-June-2017 https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2017/jun/15/cuts-fire-service-putting-lives-at-risk
- Fire Brigades Union - Save our Fire and Rescue Service - https://www.fbu.org.uk/SOFS
- List of prisons in the United Kingdom (source:wikipedia 12-June-18) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_prisons_in_the_United_Kingdom
- Prison population statistics https://www.gov.uk/government/collections/prison-population-statistics
- Are prisons in England and Wales facing a meltdown? (Source: Guardian Newsaper: Published 20-Feb-2018) https://www.theguardian.com/society/2018/feb/17/britain-prison-crisis-facing-meltdown-gangs-drugs-violence